| CommStock Israel Investor Insights Newsletter
Monday July 21, 2008
1) Oil futures: Know when to hold 'em
Rumors that Mexico is locking
in oil contracts for future delivery at today's prices prompt questions
of whether oil's record run has come to a halt.
By Steve Hargreaves,
CNNMoney.com staff writer
Last Updated: July 17, 2008: 5:35 PM EDT
NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com) -- In the last three days oil
prices have fallen by roughly $10 a barrel. Many analysts say slackening
demand, or the threat of it, is the main culprit.
But another force could be at work in the background.
Last week various analysts said there was talk that Mexico, the
world's fifth largest oil producer, was hedging its bets - the
country was said to be signing contracts to deliver oil several
years into the future at today's prices. Essentially, it was betting
oil prices have peaked.
"This is a smart move," said Phil Flynn, senior market
analyst at Alaron Trading in Chicago, who also thinks there's a
good chance prices have peaked. "If I were an oil producer, I'd
want to lock in these prices."
Analysts say if other oil producers follow suit and
lock in future contracts that could be one thing that would cause
oil prices to fall, far and fast.
But it's hard to tell if that's happening because information
about who is buying what is kept private for competitive reasons.
"I don't know who else is doing it," said Nauman Barakat,
an energy trader at Macquarie Futures, and one of the traders who
mentioned the Mexico news in a research note. "There's been a lot
of talk, but it's kept very confidential."
One analyst, speaking on background only, said he had
confirmed Mexico was locking in futures contracts. He said it was
being done at the behest of the Mexican government, eager to balance
a long-term budget, rather than a bet by state oil company PEMEX,
that prices will fall.
But could Mexico's move inspire similar steps from other
oil producers, and cause oil prices to fall further?
"Absolutely," said Neal Dingmann, senior energy analyst
at Dahlman Rose & Co., a New York-based energy investment boutique. "It
could create a top in [oil prices] in the near term."
Dingmann said about 50% of the production from the firms
he covers - mostly small firms - has been sold for future delivery
at today's prices.
Why isn't everyone doing it?
The selling from Mexico also raises another question:
Oil companies and OPEC have long said oil prices are too high -
driven by Wall Street speculators and a falling dollar rather than
supply and demand.
So if they really think prices are too high, why aren't
they all locking in contracts now?
For starters, it's believed some heavyweights, like
Saudi Arabia and Exxon Mobil, don't play the futures market at
all - they don't get into the complicated dance of buying and selling
futures contracts on NYMEX or any other markets.
In vastly simplified terms, they take whatever price
is being offered when their tankers pull into port.
Second, there aren't enough takers for these types of
contracts. There simply aren't enough people who are willing to
pay $135 dollar for a barrel of oil delivered in 2013, said Fadel
Gheit, a senior energy analyst at Oppenheimer.
"Exxon produces 1.2 billion barrels of oil a year," said
Gheit. If someone locked in all that production for five years
out at today's prices, and crude fell 20%, "it would be a disaster," he
said.
For Saudi Arabia and other OPEC counties, non-OPEC oil
producers like PEMEX locking in future contracts is a problem.
When the price of oil falls OPEC likes to pump less
oil to keep prices up. If producers sign long term contracts, they're
obligated to pump that oil making it more difficult for OPEC to
control prices.
"You get stuck with this extra production that's out
there," said John Kilduff, an energy analyst at MF Global in New
York. "Then OPEC has to reduce market share just to maintain price."
On the New York Mercantile Exchange, things are looking
fairly balanced for the first time in a long time.
Big commercial users of oil, like refineries, trucking
companies and airlines, are holding just slightly more "short" contracts
- contracts where they are betting the price of oil will fall -
than "long" contracts, according to Addison Armstrong, director
of market research at Tradition Energy Futures, an energy brokerage
based in Stamford, Conn.
Previously, commercial users had overwhelmingly been
betting prices would fall, and much of the runup in oil prices
over the last few months was a result of them selling or closing
out those short contracts and buying long ones, said Armstrong.
Meanwhile, non-commercial users - like banks and pension
funds - are holding just slightly more long positions. The market,
said Addison, is pretty well balanced.
However, that doesn't mean we won't see more of the
huge price swings of the last few days, swings that have come to
characterize the oil market of late.
"I wouldn't bet on less volatility," said Armstrong.
2) Commentary by David Zwebner,
CEO of CommStock Trading
U.S. Economy
Here is a hint of how bad things are - Citigroup lost $2.5 billion
in the second quarter, but investors are relieved (?) that it was
not as bad as analysts expected.
Grains
Dow Jones Newswires reported that Egypt bought 145,000 tons of
wheat - 60,000 tons from Russia, 25,000 tons from Ukraine, and
60,000 tons from either Canada or the U.S. December wheat closed
down 5.25 cents at $8.285.
December corn dropped 21.5 cents to $6.285, the lowest
close in seven weeks, with favorable growing conditions in the
Midwest.
Lumber
September lumber was up $1.10 at $246.60, still helped a little
by yesterday's reported 9% gain in June's housing starts.
Cocoa
The National Confectioners Association said that the U.S. cocoa
grind totaled 80,415 tons in the second quarter, down 16% from
a year ago. September cocoa fell $127 to $2,799, the lowest close
in six weeks, also blamed on fund selling.
Orange juice
September orange juice was up 1.30 cents to $1.2610 ahead of next
Thursday's USDA orange juice outlook report. The Asian citrus
psyllid remains a threat to California's orange groves.
Currencies
European Central Bank President Trichet said that he expects weak
growth in the second and third quarters of 2008, but also anticipates
a return to moderate growth in 2009. The September euro closed
up .0026 at $1.5796.
Statistics Canada said that the composite index of leading
indicators was virtually unchanged in June. In May, wholesale sales
were up 1.6% from the previous month and up 2.9% from a year ago,
stronger than expected. The September Canadian dollar was up .03
at 99.30.
The U.K.'s Office for National Statistics reported a
budget deficit of 24.4 billion pounds in the April to June quarter,
more than expected and the largest quarterly deficit since records
began in 1946.
David Zwebner, CEO
CommStock Trading Ltd.
Tel: +972-(0)2 624-4963
Fax: +972-(0)2 624-4876
www.ecommstock.com
3) A Fan of Forex?
Interested in reading perspectives and analyses on the
Forex market? In learning what factors affect the Forex market
every week and what to be on the lookout for? In getting trade
recommendations? Email mona@ecommstock.com to
get your copy of a weekly Forex report.
4) Closing Prices for Friday, July
18, 2008
Amidex: Amidex35 (Class No Load Shares),
$15.39; Index, 2226.59, Daily Change,-2.02%; “A” Shares NAV, $11.99.
Global Asset Management: Capital
Appreciation, $258.99; Composite Absolute Return, $912.10; Diversity,
$741.05; GAMCO, $861.56; Interest Trend, $260.12; Trading IV-US$
Class, $150.26; US$ Special Bond Fund, $442.32.
Invesco: Asian Equity Core, $4.65; Bond, $25.93;
Emerging Markets Bond, $19.74; European Bond, EUR 4.2576; Gilt,
GBP 11.76; Global High Income, $11.60; Japanese Equity Core,
$1.36; UK Equity, GBP 4.80.
JPMorgan Fleming: JF Eastern Smaller
Co., $99.24; JF Japan, JPY 16,769; JF Japan Equity, $12.72;
JF Japan OTC, JPY 1,038; JF Japan Smaller Companies,
JPY 37,690; JF Japan Technology, JPY 47,554; JF Korea, $38.22;
Pacific Securities, $192.20; Pacific Smaller Companies $22.19;
Global Bond & Currency, $22.18;
JF America, $42.67; JF Europe, $46.38; JF Germany, EUR
20.39; JF Global Equity, $39.88.
PCP: North America, $12.16; Europe,
$19.40; Emerging Markets, $18.37; Balanced, $8.50; Aggressive,
$7.21.
Platinum (updated once a month – June 2008 Prices): All
Weather, $127.43; Equity Plus, TBA; Prot. Equity Plus, TBA; Cap.
Prot. Income Plus, TBA; Cap. Prot. Income Plus A, TBA.
Scottish Provident: Adventurous 1,
GBP 2.723; Balanced 1, GBP 2.264; USD Adventurous 1, $2.212;
USD Balanced 1, $2.161; USD Cautious 1, $2.055; For
Preference: Baring GUF Eastern Europe, $154.99; Fidelity
Funds International, $34.660; Invesco Asian Equity Core, $4.660.
CommStock Trading Ltd
PO Box 7777
Jerusalem 91077
Tel: +972-2-6244963
Fax: +972-2-625 9515
|